Isabel II, niña

Isabel II, niña

  • 1838
  • Oil on canvas
  • 167 x 126 cm
  • Cat. P_211
  • Commissioned from the artist by the Banco Español de San Fernando in 1838
  • Observations: Antes de que se reconociese la firma, el cuadro estuvo atribuido a Genaro Pérez Villaamil.
By:

Born on 10 October 1830, Isabella II was eight years old when she posed for this portrait, and had already been the Queen of Spain for five years. The iconography could not be more expressive of her complex condition. Standing before the throne, a canopy over her and a footstool beside her, she points with her left hand to the symbolic royal regalia while her right hand holds her glove. However, the queen is dressed in a revelatory fashion, with a child’s costume that does not fulfil court requisites yet includes certain elements pertaining to the attire of an adult woman. Suitably, the outfit is of white silk, the colour reserved for the Catholic Queens, woven with silver braid of a sumptuousness proper to the wearer, but the type of clothing is that of a small girl, with Turkish-style pantaloons and a sylph dress with a flared skirt and white bodice. The off-the-shoulder neckline with its rich organza trim and the puffed sleeves are replicas for children of the tastes promoted by fashion magazines for adult women. Isabella II is shown with hardly any personal adornments, as befitted a little girl, but she wears rich fabrics and pearls, which were by definition the adornment of married women, as well as a characteristically Spanish tortoiseshell back comb. All this makes up an ambiguous image of the child queen, half public and half private, with an outfit somewhere between a court gown and the dress of any little girl from the bourgeoisie or aristocracy, and an image falling between that of a head of state and an eight-year-old girl. This characterisation contrasts with that devised for her by other painters like Vicente López [Museo del Prado, P7544, on long-term loan to Tribunal Supremo, Madrid], who likewise shows her under a canopy before the throne, but dresses her in a white court dress with a velvet train in Bourbon blue. The royal mantle is seen behind, the crown and sceptre lie beneath her right hand, and she is adorned with a diadem and jewels appropriate to an adult woman. The comparison reveals the problematics of composing a royal portrait in the early years of this reign.

In this debate between the different court sensibilities on the best manner of portraying the child queen once she had ceased to appear in the arms of her mother, then still Regent, it was predominantly López’s concept that held sway, and it was afterwards adopted by the rest of the court painters, among them Luis de la Cruz, José de Madrazo and Carlos Luis de Ribera. Such a preference formed an integral part of the fascination this unusual little girl held for her contemporaries. Just as fate had placed a premature crown in the remote past on the heads of children whose future had been judged uncertain, the little Isabella, as Reyero has put it well (Reyero 2004: 234-237), incarnated a poetic contrast that condensed the Romantic outlook on life, with feminine tenderness and infantile fragility on the one hand, and on the other the tough responsibility of ruling a country submerged in the gravest of crises. The queen would have to oppose the absolutist option represented by the pretender to the throne, her uncle Carlos María Isidro, and in this respect, Esquivel believed, the childish characteristics visible in his portrait also denote a clear ray of hope in a nascent constitutional future. The orphaned daughter of Ferdinand VII signified the only chance for the desired political renewal, whereas her uncle proposed the continuity of the Ancien Régime. A committed liberal who fought against the Hundred Thousand Sons of Saint Louis, Esquivel thus turned the vulnerability of the little girl who appears in the picture into an element addressed to the common protective instinct of adults, alerting them to the fact that the democratic assurances brought by liberalism to Spain were still frail.

Despite the extraordinary artistic quality of Esquivel’s portrait within the context of his own production, his model did not catch on as an official image of the queen precisely because it was seen as too daring. Even so, the artist went on to portray Isabella as a child queen on other occasions. The most memorable is without doubt the portrait forming a pair with that of her sister Luisa Fernanda (Sanlúcar de Barrameda, private collection), dating from the same year as the Banco de España portrait. The two children, still schoolgirls, look out at the viewer, one on the throne and the other from a chair. Once again, reality in both cases is revealed through details – Isabella II is studying, but Luisa Fernanda is in fact only playing – that emphasise their fragility. When viewed alongside the portrait of her sister, busy with activities typical of her age, it is easier to understand the hope with which Esquivel impregnated the image of the queen, but at the same time the uncertainty hanging over her destiny.

Carlos González Navarro

One of the most represented personages in the Banco de España’s painting collection is Queen Isabella II (1830-1904), not only because her reign was comparatively long (1833-1868) but also because the Banco de San Fernando and the Banco de Isabel II coexisted for much of it until they were merged in 1847. These official banking institutions were set up under the patronage of monarchs, whose names they would frequently take (San Carlos, San Fernando), and they needed portraits of those monarchs to be displayed in the most important places from the perspective of their representative role.

Isabella II was the daughter of Ferdinand VII of Spain. Her appointment as crown princess led to a serious political crisis in Spain triggered by the supporters of her uncle, Infante Carlos María Isidro of Spain, who were opposed to a woman reigning. That crisis resulted in the bloody conflicts known as the ‘Carlist Wars”. She was a minor (she was three years old when her father died), so initially her mother Maria Christina acted as regent until 1840. General Espartero then succeeded her as regent until Isabella was declared to be of age in 1843 to avoid further regencies. In 1846 she married her cousin Francisco de Asís. Apart from the succession problems, her reign was noted for frequent political crises, which ended in the so-called 1868 Revolution, after which Isabella II went into exile in France, where she stayed until her death. It was a time of certain economic and industrial prosperity, which saw the birth and rapid development of the railway in Spain and the undertaking of major public works, the disentailment of ecclesiastical property, and the making of great fortunes, such as that of the Marquis of Salamanca.

In 1838, when the country was under the regency of Maria Christina, Antonio María Esquivel painted the earliest portrait of Isabella II, which is held by the Banco de España. She is standing with a comb in her hair, holding a white glove in her hand, and wearing the sash of the Order of Queen Maria Luisa. Her left hand (which is gloved) is pointing to a small table with an opulent red cover embroidered with the coat of arms of Spain.  A cushion bearing the sceptre and crown is on the table. There is a gilded wooden throne with red upholstery behind the child queen. It is engraved with motifs alluding to her status: two angels on the back are holding a coat of arms with a ‘Y’ and a ‘2’ in one hand and a royal crown in the other. When Esquivel painted the portrait of Isabella II, he had seen one of Ferdinand VII (which is now also in the Banco de España Collection) which is currently attributed to Zacarías González Velázquez. The composition is very similar: he is also standing next to a table with a crown and a cushion, before a throne with his initials on the back and with two angels holding a crown of Spain. The attire is different, as the king is wearing a military uniform and holding a staff of command. The style is also different. The execution of the painting of Isabella II is very careful, meticulous and painstaking, as is characteristic of Esquivel’s portraits. It also shows his characteristic liking of pearly tones to depict flesh. As far as colour is concerned, the artist here opts for combining red and golden tones to create a striking, sumptuous frame for the figure of Isabella II as a child. The result is one of the most delicate images of her rich iconography.

Javier Portús

 
By:
Javier Portús
Antonio María Esquivel y Suárez de Urbina
Sevilla 1806 - Madrid 1857

As with many Sevillian painters of his time, his biography revolves around that city, where he studied with Francisco Gutiérrez at the School of Fine Arts and was taught to admire Murillo; and Madrid, where he moved in 1831, thanks to the patronage of the British consul in Seville. The following year, he was named academician of merit by the Academy of San Fernando, and once he had settled at court, he began making a place for himself in that city’s art market, becoming a part of local art circles by helping to found cultural organisations, making contact with writers, and even writing art criticism himself. His interest in the arts and letters made him a typical representative of Romanticism, and this is visible in paintings such as Ventura de la Vega Reading a Work at the Teatro del Príncipe (Museo del Romanticismo, Madrid) and The Contemporary Poets, A Reading of Zorrilla at the Painter’s Studio (Museo Nacional del Prado, Madrid).

He was one of the founders of Madrid’s Liceo Artístico y Literario in 1837, and the following year, he travelled to Seville to organize the Liceo Sevillano. There he became blind, but with the help of his friends, painters and writers, he was able to travel abroad, where his condition was cured in June 1840. The following year, he returned to his brilliant career in Madrid and two years later he was appointed court painter. In 1847, he was promoted to full membership of the Academy of San Fernando. His interest in participating in local art events is exemplified by his presence in 1856, just a year before his death, in the first National Exhibition of Fine Arts. Esquivel exercised influence on the art scene in Madrid through both his teaching and his Tratado de anatomía pictórica (Treatise on Pictorial Anatomy), first published in 1848.

He was a prolific painter, and while his catalogue includes a considerable variety of genres, his speciality was portraiture. Queens, infantas, politicians, soldiers, noblemen, the bourgeoisie and writers are the models for his individual and group portraits, and they allow us to recognise the protagonists of Romanticism in Madrid, as well as the middle and upper classes of his time. He produced a smaller number of religious paintings, with early works clearly indebted to Murillo and an evolution towards chromatic and compositional simplicity that approaches the work of the Nazarenes. He also painted historical and mythological images, as well as a few costumbrista works set in his native city, and even a few erotic paintings — something infrequent among Spanish painters of the time.

Javier Portús

 
By:
Paloma Gómez Pastor
Isabel II Isabella II (Madrid 1830 - Paris 1904)
Queen of Spain 1833 - 1868

María Isabel Luisa de Borbón y Borbón was the eldest daughter of Ferdinand VII and his fourth wife, Maria Christina of Bourbon Two Sicilies. Her birth was greatly desired, as her father had had no descent by his three previous marriages, but it also divided Spain into two sides, since the First Carlist War broke out just two days after the death of Ferdinand VII on 29 September 1833. Her uncle, Carlos María Isidro, did not recognise her as the legitimate queen, even though Ferdinand VII had repealed the Auto Acordado (Agreed Writ) of Philip V and re-established the Spanish monarchic tradition whereby a woman could rule. Isabella took the oath as Princess of Asturias on 20 June 1833, and was proclaimed queen on 24 October the same year. Aged three when she came to the throne, the regents during her minority reign (1833-1843) were first her mother, Queen Maria Christina, and then General Espartero.

Maria Christina’s regency lasted from 1833 to 1840. It was during this regency that the moderate Royal Statute of 1834 was issued, followed by the progressivist Constitution of 1837. Queen Maria Christina had to renounce the regency in 1840 and depart for exile in France. The parliamentary Cortes appointed General Espartero as sole regent, and chose Agustín de Argüelles as tutor to Isabella and Luisa Fernanda. In his turn, he appointed the Countess of Espoz y Mina as governess.

In 1843, after the downfall of Espartero, the Cortes decided to declare Isabella II, who had just turned thirteen, to have come of age. The reign of Isabella II was characterised by political instability, uprisings, military coups and a large number of governments, while at the same time Spain began its process of modernisation.

Queen Isabella II’s first government was led by Salustiano Olózaga, the head of the Progressivist Party, who was replaced by the moderate government of Luis González Bravo. On 3 May 1844, General Narváez came to power, marking the beginning of a period of ten years of moderate governments, the so-called Moderate Decade (1844-1854). Narváez presided over four governments, all dominated by a moderate party of which he was the leader and bulwark from 1843 to 1868. Besides being the strong man of the Moderate Decade, he was the true protagonist of Isabella’s reign.

The governments of France and England intervened actively in the marriages of Isabella II and her sister Luisa Fernanda, both powers fearing that a royal marriage might bestow supremacy on the other. The two powers reached an agreement whereby Isabella could marry only a descendant of Philip V. The Infante Francisco de Asís was chosen by a process of exclusion. He was perhaps not the most suitable husband for the young, extroverted and lively Isabella II, who was not at all enthusiastic about marrying a cousin whose physical appearance and taciturn character were completely unattractive to her. On 10 October 1846, at the age of sixteen, she was married at the Royal Palace in Madrid. Simultaneously, the Infanta Luisa Fernanda was wedded to Antoine d’Orléans, Duke of Montpensier, the ninth child of King Louis- Philippe of France.

The project to reform the Constitution of 1845 led to the downfall of Bravo Murillo and emphasised the decline of the moderate party. His successors represented the most extreme reaction of the moderates, contributing to the formation of a revolutionary front that put an end to the Moderate Decade and originated the Revolution of 1854. Of all that Revolution’s consequences, the most serious was the damage to the queen’s prestige.

Faced with such a grave situation, the queen called on Espartero, who governed for two years, the Progressivist Biennium (1854-1856), while O’Donnell took over the War Minister portfolio. After a parenthesis of two years of moderate governments (1856-1858), O’Donnell returned with his second government, the so-called ‘long government’ or Progressivist Quinquennium (1858-1863). These were five years of peace and political and economic stability. The most outstanding development during this period was the building and opening of the railways, which not only made communications easier but also helped consolidate Spain’s towns and cities as urban centres.

The Quinquennium ended with the crisis caused by O’Donnell’s decision to carry out a ministerial reshuffle, which led to Prim’s leaving the Unionist Party to join the progressivists. The crisis was worsened by a confrontation between the queen and the head of her government, culminating in Isabella’s refusal to sign the decree to dissolve parliament that was requested by the latter in order to be able to initiate constitutional reform. With the downfall of O’Donnell, the twilight of Isabella’s reign began.

The governments under the successive presidencies of the Marquis of Miraflores, Arrazola and Mon were followed on 16 September 1864 by a new Narváez Government, which was dissolved in 1865 after major student protests had been violently repressed on the ‘Night of Saint Daniel’. Narváez’s exit was followed by the last government of O’Donnell (1865- 1866), faced with the now unstoppable conspiracies of the progressivists, who had decided to take the path of revolution.

In 1866, there was a succession of uprisings led by Prim. The one at the Artillery Barracks of San Gil in Madrid degenerated into a street battle followed by harsh repression, undermining both the traditional generosity of the queen and the liberal sympathies of O’Donnell, the Duke of Tetuán. The queen replaced him with Narváez, while O’Donnell went into voluntary exile in Biarritz (France). Isabella II thus lost one of the most loyal and valuable men of her reign. Narváez presided over what was to be his last government, from July 1866 to April 1868, when he suspended parliament and the constitutional guarantees.

The response of the progressivists was not long in coming. In August 1866 they signed the Pact of Ostend, in which they committed themselves to forming a single front to bring down the regime and the dynasty, creating a permanent revolutionary centre in Brussels. Upon O’Donnell’s death in 1867, the Liberal Union joined the Pact. When Narváez died in 1868, the queen was left without support. She appointed González Bravo to preside over her government, but he governed with a dictatorial style that merely precipitated Isabella II’s deposition.

The Revolution was led by Generals Serrano and Prim together with Admiral Topete. They arrived in Cádiz and Gibraltar on 17 and 19 September 1868. On 30 September, Isabella II left San Sebastián to cross the French border. She was nearly 38. The ‘Glorious Revolution’ put an end to her reign.

In exile, she first took up residence at the Château de Pau, placed at her disposal by Napoleon III. After the first few months, she separated definitively, and by mutual accord, from her consort. Isabella II then moved to Paris, making her final home at the Basilewsky Palace, to which she gave the name of the Palace of Castile. There, on 25 June 1870, she abdicated in favour of her son, Alfonso XII, and put Cánovas at the head of the Alfonsine movement. She died on 9 April 1904 of pneumonia brought on by influenza. The French government dispensed honours befitting a Head of State to the woman who had been Queen of Spain for 35 years, and had lived in Paris for 37. The queen’s coffin was solemnly conveyed to the Gare d’Orsay, where it was taken by train to Spain to be buried in the Royal Mausoleum at the monastery of El Escorial.

Despite the political instability of the period, Spain’s modernisation was hastened by the 35-year reign of Isabella II before her deposition in 1868. The population grew considerably, and the first official census of 1857 put its number at 15,500,000. The railway network started to be laid out in 1848, and 5,400 kilometres of track were opened for use in 1855.

In 1845, major financial reforms were begun. Ramón de Santillán was one of those involved in these measures, which were applied by Alejandro Mon. In 1856, Banco de España was created out of the merger of Banco de San Fernando and Banco de Isabel II. The application of the new banking laws paved the way for the founding of issuing banks and loan companies.

Disentailment helped to increase the area of cultivated land. The cotton and wool textile industry underwent a rapid process of expansion and concentration, especially after the import of English machinery in 1842. Mining began on a large scale in the second half of the nineteenth century. The construction of public works was especially notable during the governments of Bravo Murillo and O’Donnell. More than 7,000 kilometres of roads were built, and canals like those of Isabel II, Tauste, Imperial and Castilla helped to develop systems of irrigation and water supplies for urban centres. The postage stamp and the telegraph also appeared in 1854. Gas lighting entered service in 1841, and the first tests on electric street lighting were carried out in Barcelona in 1852.

Photography began in Spain in the midnineteenth century, and Charles Clifford and Jean Laurent both worked for the Court. Cultural development was also considerable. Claudio Moyano’s first Law of Public Instruction was promulgated, and the Academy of Moral and Political Sciences was founded. By a law of 12 May 1865, Isabella II donated her private collections to the Museo del Prado, where they today form the museum’s most important repertory of works. In 1836, moreover, the Royal Library ceased to be the property of the Crown and came under the administration of the Ministry of Governance, whereupon it was renamed the Biblioteca Nacional (National Library). It was during Isabella II’s reign, whether by purchase, donation or confiscation, that the Library acquired most of the oldest books it currently possesses. On 21 April 1866, the queen laid the first stone of the building that now houses the National Library, designed by Francisco Jareño. It was also during her reign, thanks in large measure to her fondness for opera, that Madrid’s opera house, the Teatro Real, was inaugurated on 19 November 1850 with Donizetti’s La Favorita, and that the genre of the zarzuela, the Spanish operetta, was reborn.

Isabella II had ten children, five of whom survived into adulthood: Isabel (very popular in Madrid, where she was affectionately called La Chata), Alfonso (the future Alfonso XII), Pilar, Paz and Eulalia.

Paloma Gómez Pastor

 
«El Banco de España. Dos siglos de historia (1782-1982)», Banco de España (Madrid, 1982). «Masterpieces from the Banco de España Collection», Museo de Bellas Artes de Santander (Santander, 1993). «150 Years of Saving in Spain», Confederación Española de Cajas de Ahorro (Madrid, 2003). «Liberalism & Romanticism in the time of Isabella II», Museo Arqueológico Nacional (Madrid, 2004). «2328 reales de vellón. Goya and the Origins of the Banco de España Collection», Banco de España (Madrid, 2021-2022).
Vv.Aa. El Banco de España. Dos siglos de historia. 1782-1982, Madrid, Banco de España, 1982. Julián Gállego Banco de España. Colección de pintura, «Catálogo de pintura del siglo XIX en el Banco de España», Madrid, Banco de España, 1985. Julián Gállego & María José Alonso Colección de pintura del Banco de España, «Pintura de los siglos XIX y XX en la colección del Banco de España», Madrid, Banco de España, 1988. Enrique Valdivieso & José Fernández López Pintura romántica sevillana, Seville, Fundación Endesa, 2011. Vv.Aa. Colección Banco de España. Catálogo razonado, Madrid, Banco de España, 2019, vol. 1. Vv.Aa. 2328 reales de vellón. Goya y los orígenes de la Colección Banco de España, Madrid, Banco de España, 2021.